Skip to main content

LATEST NEWS

Colleges are clearly the answer – so why do we keep asking the same questions?

by Gavin Donoghue, CEO, Colleges Scotland (originally appeared in The Times, Thunderer column)

Scottish Government Ministers have no shortage of tricky questions to tackle ahead of their draft Budget on 3 December: how do we sustainably grow our economy? How do we eradicate child poverty? And how do we ensure employers can find the right skilled workers to grow their businesses? 

What can surely no longer be questioned, however, is that increasing the vocational and technical education provided by colleges is the answer to many of Scotland’s challenges.

The Milburn Review tells us that increased college places and apprenticeships open up job opportunities, especially for those not in education, employment or training, and that the best systems in the world have a strong backbone of vocational education and training. In Scotland, although funding for Modern Apprenticeships has recently risen by 10%, we still need to see more apprenticeships being delivered, and for funding to reflect their actual costs.

When it comes to reducing poverty, and especially child poverty, the Fraser of Allander Institute has demonstrated the value of colleges. As community anchors, colleges keep 15,000 people out of absolute poverty, with over 400,000 households – including 250,000 children – benefitting from the higher incomes earned by those with a college education.

As for sustainably growing our economy, colleges already provide over 14,000 Modern Apprenticeships a year, and every college graduate creates an additional £72,000 boost to productivity across their 40-year working life – making the Scottish economy cumulatively better off by around £52bn. 

Even though Scotland’s colleges so obviously help government deliver its priorities it is always with a sense of trepidation that they enter the draft Budget period. This is because colleges have already absorbed a real-terms funding cut of 7.5% since 2021/22. The result of this has been stark but predictable: 40,000 fewer students, a 13% reduction in staff headcount, and growing financial pressures across the sector. 

Nineteen of our 24 colleges are forecast to face operating deficits in the years ahead, according to the Scottish Funding Council, and if there is flat cash funding some colleges will struggle to maintain sufficient cash to pay their staff or suppliers.

This is not merely a problem for colleges. It is a problem for Scotland.

Economic growth comes from investment in innovation and skills. Yet there has been significant underinvestment in the frontline institutions helping deliver the skilled workforce we need.

Employers regularly tell us they need technicians, engineers, digital specialists, construction workers, carers, and skilled tradespeople. Demand is rising, but the capacity of colleges to respond has been steadily eroded. 

The Scottish Government’s own Public Service Reform strategy talks about preventative spend. Colleges are prevention in action. They help people back into jobs before unemployment becomes entrenched. They equip workers with new skills before industries decline. They create opportunity, often in our most deprived communities, before disadvantage becomes permanent.

Given the clear positive return on investment, the question should be can our country really afford not to invest in college education, training and skills?

×

Members’ Area

The Members’ Area contains information for Chairs and Principals of colleges in Scotland. The information in these sections are intended for those issued with log-in details only, it should be treated as confidential and not for wider circulation.